4 - Duns Scotus’s Modal Theory Cambridge Companions Online - Cambridge University Press

Please wait, page is loading...

Cambridge University Press home


4 - Duns Scotus’s Modal Theory

pp. 129-160

  • The Cambridge Companion to Duns Scotus
  • Edited by:
  • Publisher:

  • Online Publication Date:
  • May 2006
  • Print Publication Year:
  • 2002

  • Hardback ISBN:
  • 9780521632058
  • Online ISBN:
  • 9780511998881
  • Paperback ISBN:
  • 9780521635639

Recent interest in John Duns Scotus’s modal theory derives largely from the suggestion that Scotus was the first in the Middle Ages, and perhaps the first ever, to employ a synchronic conception of modality, one that allowed for alternative possibilities at a given time, and from the debate about whether Scotus introduced a notion of logical possibility divorced from any question of what powers there are. These issues interact in the question of whether Scotus had any analogue of the notion of possible world in either the Leibnizian or the late twentieth-century sense. Late medieval interest in Scotus’s modal theory derived largely from its role in his account of divine and human freedom and from the debate about whether possibility itself depended in any way upon God. This discussion attempts to shed some light on these issues and to locate them in the context of the issues in the theory of modality with which Scotus and his contemporaries were themselves concerned.

It would be desirable in an essay of this kind to present a picture of the development of Scotus’s thought about modality, but in the current state of scholarship that is not possible. Despite nearly a century of work by the Scotus Commission and by a number of very able scholars outside it, our understanding of the textual tradition of Scotus’s works remains radically incomplete. In such a situation any hypothesis about the development of Scotus’s modal theory must be highly speculative. In what follows I will not attempt to trace such a development but will attempt to limn the modal theory with which Scotus seems to have been working at the end of his (unfortunately short) life.

Welcome to Cambridge Companions Online

Buy this book

To buy this print book online, or for more information please visit The Cambridge University Press online catalogue below

Buy the print book now

To access this eBook please subscribe